Will a kind doctor help you feel better?
The placebo effect – where medication can make you feel better because you think it will, even if it doesn’t have active ingredients – has been area of fascination for decades.
Equally fascinating is the nocebo effect, the opposite of placebo, where you think that a medication or treatment will do something bad to you, and that expectation leads to the negative effect happening, even when you’ve only taken a sugar pill.
But most of the placebo/nocebo research involves giving patients a pill, cream, or other sham treatment. Can a doctor’s words alone induce similar effects in people?
In an experiment at a doctor’s office, 76 people were given a histamine skin prick, which induces irritation and itchiness. They rated how itchy their arm felt every few minutes after the prick.
In one group, three minutes after the skin prick, the doctor looked at their arm and gave them assurances that their allergic reaction would now start to decrease, and their rash would go away. In the other group, the doctor only looked at the reaction on the person’s arm, but said nothing.
What they found was that for the first three minutes, itchiness and irritation increased in a similar amount for both groups. But after the doctor’s reassurance, that group of patients immediately felt significantly less itchy, and it continued to reduce over time at a faster rate than the group who were told nothing.
After nine minutes, both of the groups felt roughly the same – the difference was that the group who were reassured saw a sudden improvement, much faster, right after they were spoken to by the doctor.
The researchers say that this demonstrates the power of a doctor’s words in a consultation, even when there’s no medication or treatment being offered. They also think that the response shown in the experiment is probably at the lower end of how effective it could be – given all of the patients were healthy and it was a low-stress situation.
What’s more, it was just a single sentence of reassurance – the effect may be even greater if consistent and repeated assurances were made by the doc.
Plus, you know the night-and-day difference between visiting a doctor who really seems to care about your condition, versus one who’s just ticking the boxes.
It makes a difference to how positive you feel at the end of the consult, and it seems it might help you get better, faster, too.
Last Reviewed: 20/02/2020
© Norman Swan Medical Communications.
For reference: Leibowitz, et al. (2019). Physician Assurance Reduces Patient Symptoms in US Adults: an Experimental Study. Journal of General Internal Medicine doi: 10.1007/s11606-018-4627-z.
Skin cancer: what is it?
Understanding the main types of skin cancer: basal cell carcinoma, melanoma and squamous cell carcinoma and skin cancer treatment options.
Video: Antidepressants work, but some better than others
A large analysis has found 21 different antidepressants to be better than a placebo (dummy treatment), however side-effects meant they were stopped more often than placebo.
Bowel cancer treatments
There are different types of treatment for bowel cancer depending on what stage the cancer is, that is the type and size of the cancer and whether it has begun to spread.
Medicines: understanding your medicines
When your doctor gives you a prescription for a medicine, it has been a careful process and you have been part of the decision making.
If you have impotence (erectile dysfunction), the treatment your doctor recommends will depend on the severity of your symptoms and the underlying cause of your impotence.