Chiropractic no better than sham treatment for thoracic back pain
Techniques used by chiropractors to treat thoracic spine pain (pain of the upper and middle back) are no better than sham therapy, an Australian study shows.
A research team from the discipline of chiropractic at Murdoch University’s School of Health investigated spinal manipulative therapy and the Graston technique to determine their effectiveness in relieving pain and disability in spine pain compared with sham treatment.
The Graston technique uses a hand-held instrument to detect and break down scar tissue and fascial restrictions to boost mobilisation.
The study included 143 adults with ongoing non-specific thoracic spine pain who were randomly allocated to receive either spinal manipulative therapy, the Graston technique or sham treatment, which involved non-functional ultrasound.
Each participant received up to 10 supervised treatment sessions at the university’s chiropractic student clinic in Perth over a 4-week period.
The study found that there was no differences in the treatment groups for pain or disability at any point in time following the start of treatment, from one week to 12 months.
However, there were improvements in pain and disability over time in all 3 groups.
“These results constitute the first from a fully powered randomised controlled trial, comparing [spinal manipulative therapy], Graston technique and a placebo.
“It indicates that there is no difference in outcome at any point in time for pain and disability … however, all groups improved with time,” the authors concluded.
Last Reviewed: 20/05/2016
Reproduced with kind permission from Australian Doctor
Video: Back pain
Back pain is a common symptom of different underlying conditions such as arthritis and muscular sprains. Most back pain improves with appropriate treatment. However, prevention through good posture and safe lifting is equally important.
Video: Cervical radiculopathy
In cervical radiculopathy, a nerve in your neck (the cervical spine) becomes pinched. This can affect nerves that travel to your arms, shoulder and hands, causing weakness, numbness, pins and needles or pain.
Video: Spinal stenosis
Spinal stenosis is an abnormal narrowing of the spinal canal that can cause varying symptoms, depending on the location and severity of the narrowing. Symptoms may include numbness, weakness or pain in the limbs, as well as bladder, bowel or sexual dysfunction. Treatment can include physical therapy, medication and surgery.
Most Australian adults will experience low back pain at some time in their lives. Most uncomplicated low back pain resolves after a period of active recovery and people are generally back to normal within 4 weeks.
Neck pain: treatment
Treatment for neck pain depends on the cause and how severe it is. Neck pain treatment, including treatment for whiplash, often involves a combination of self-care, medicines, exercises and relaxation therapies.