5:2 diet no more effective than continuous dieting
Intermittent fasting, made popular by the 5:2 diet, is no more effective at promoting weight loss than continuous dieting, a scientific review shows.
Routinely touted as the superior weight loss option, the 5:2 diet allows people to eat as usual for five days and then fast for two. For women, the “fasting” phase means eating 500 calories per day while men are allowed 600 calories.
The rationale behind this hugely popular eating pattern is that a period of non-fasting is followed by a short period of fasting or severe energy restriction and this has a metabolic advantage.
However, a review of 52 studies by researchers from the University of Sydney has found that while intermittent fasting results in weight loss – at least in the short term – it is no better than continuous energy restriction, i.e. being on a continuous diet.
The results suggest that intermittent fasting has no physiological benefits over continuous dieting for weight loss, say the researchers.
Instead, they found that both dieting strategies produced equivalent outcomes in terms of reduction of body weight, fat mass and fat-free mass. Furthermore, both diets showed similar dropout rates and improved stability of blood glucose levels.
Last Reviewed: 22/09/2015
Seimon RV, et al. Do intermittent diets provide physiological benefits over continuous diets for weight loss? A systematic review of clinical trials. Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology doi:10.1016/j.mce.2015.09.014.
Is a fasting diet a good long-term weight loss solution?
Intermittent fasting diets have gained a lot of attention, popularised by Dr Michael Mosley’s 5:2 Fast Diet, but is it a good option for long-term weight loss?
Why does weight go back on?
Research into a drug for type 2 diabetes may inadvertently help to explain that weight regain for people that diet to lose weight is not a simple matter of poor self-control.
Why you should avoid weekend food binges
If you eat a healthy diet all week, only to binge on junk food at the weekends, then you may be undoing all your good work.
Switching to a vegetarian diet cuts kilos
A review of clinical trials has found that a vegetarian diet prescribed as a lifestyle change is effective in helping with weight loss.
Exercise to burn fat
Find out about which types of exercise are best to burn fat and help you lose weight. To reduce total body fat, focus on increasing your physical activity, rather than decreasing energy consumed.